4- Some folks think that True Zen is about iconoclasm ... smash the statues, skip the boring ceremonies and arcane rituals, only do the stuff that is not "stupid"
Yes, there is that. But folks who think it is mostly that do not know their history of Zen.
... even the great "iconoclastic" Tang Dynasty Zen masters probably lived within a monastic system so hide bound, ritual laden and behavior restricted that their "iconoclasm" was any minor breach of the rigid rules! "Oh, he kicked over the water bucket ... he used his left hand instead of his right hand to place the incense ... what a 'free spirit' he must be!" :roll:
Baloney!
The fact is that these guys were monks, following the Chinese version of the Vinaya, and there "transgressions" where "shocking" just because of the tremendous rigidity of their life ...
And that is actually something very valuable about this practice that some folks miss:
Namely, there is much about Zen practice that involves doing inefficient, hide bound, ritual laden, behavior restricted dumb, unfair and boring stuff ... BECAUSE IT IS DUMB, BORING and BEHAVIOR RESTRICTED, because it is not what you "want to do". Reason? Life in general is often inefficient, behavior restricted, boring and not what we "want to do" ... and if you can learn freedom amid the restrictions, well, that is true freedom.
Outward lack of freedom of choice can teach us about inner freedom too.
I used to volunteer as a Zen teacher in a maximum security prison. I noticed that the structure of a prison is much like a monastery, actually (except for the guards and violence of course

), with a daily schedule filled with fixed, rigid, pointless, boring rituals that one often does not want to do. But the lack of outward freedom and the set routine can teach us an inner tranquility and freedom that even monastery/prison walls cannot hold ... and one learns how to handle dull, pointless, silly, waste of time, arcane, "I hate this" rituals BECAUSE one resists doing them. It is a part of the training. Why? BECAUSE life is so often what we do not like it to be ... and thus we learn to find freedom amid what we resist and do not like.
That is one reason I often engage in practices I REALLY HATE, THINK OF AS 'DUMB' AND FIND I RESIST ... like holding the Sutra book a certain way, bowing a certain way, chanting a certain way.
Folks who run away from everything they don't "like" in traditional Zen practice, and who cannot find freedom even when compelled to do something they resist, will be doing that through much of the rest of their lives too.
That does not mean that you need to do everything just because it is unpleasant, and it does not mean you cannot pick and choose to leave behind some rituals and such which do not speak to you. However, a good part of your practice must be activities that are not "fun", that you do not "enjoy", which you find "dumb" or "boring" ... and which you "resist" a bit. Because if you want your practice to always be "fun" and "make sense" ... well, good chance you do not understand real "freedom".
That also does not mean that one cannot practice with all the "unpleasantries" of general life, without adding practice with the artificial "unpleasantries" of Zen monastic life. However, consider the latter ... when done well ... like the artificial "flight simulator" that helps the pilot when it is actually time to fly a real plane.
Bookmarks