Quote:
Originally Posted by Deadbuddha
I don't claim to be an expert on koans. I've done a little reading on them. What I understand is when someone says something, typically we carry the logic forward (accept their sentiment and make it our own) and come to what we understand as "true" (either agreeing or disagreeing) and/or form some kind of mental construct. However, as a koan, we must understand that what someone tells us is nothing near true (nor can it be by the nature of language and emptiness), instead of carrying the logic forward and arriving at some artificial "truth" or mental construct, we acknowledge what we hear, we let it go, and we see that the best (?) response is already in us. We just need to let the response come from that source within us which is true realization or insight. This is why we sit zazen (I think there are many "whys").
Hi DB,
Quote:
Blue Cliff Record Case 55: Dogo's Condolence Visit
Master Dogo and [his student] Zengen came to a house [for a funeral] to express condolences. Zengen tapped on the
coffin and said,
"Is this life or death?"
Dogo said,
"I don't say life, I don't say death."
Zengen said,
"Why don't you?"
Dogo said,
"I won't say, I won't say."
Master Dogo did not say the guy is "not dead" ... but, simultaneously true, what is there when we drop from mind all mental categories of "life" and "death" "start" and "finish" "coming" and "going" "inside the coffin" and "outside" ?? ... SPEAK! SPEAK! 8)
Quote:
Dogen also said, “This action, that is, cutting the cat, is nothing other than Buddha’s action.”
Ejo said, “What shall we call it?”
Dogen said, “Call it cutting the cat.”
Ejo asked, “Is it a [Karmic] crime or not?”
Dogen said, “Yes, it is a crime.”
Ejo inquired, “How are we able to be released from it?”
Dogen said, “Buddha’s action and the criminal action are separate, yet they both occur in one action.”
Dogen, the great "word-smith" and poet, was not about abandoning words in our practice ... he was about using them in a crafty and "mind shaking" fashion to get at truths beyond truths.